Original title: Culture and constitutional compliance
Jerg Gutmann, Anna Lewczuk-Czerwińska, Jacek Lewkowicz, Stefan Voigt · August 2026
A constitution sets the legal rules for a country, but leaders in some nations follow these rules while leaders in others ignore them. Researchers wanted to know why this happens and whether national culture plays a role. They looked at 115 countries using new measures of how well governments obey their own constitutions. They found that societies where people are more individualistic show higher levels of compliance with their constitutions. In these cultures, promises made by leaders to follow constitutional limits become more credible. This shows that written rules depend heavily on unwritten cultural habits. The researchers also found patterns matching past studies that link lower institutional quality to slower development in the modern Muslim world.
Imagine a group of friends agreeing to split a dinner bill evenly. Everyone says they'll pay, but when the check comes, some people suddenly forget their wallets. The agreement only works if each person feels a strong sense of personal responsibility to follow through. In this paper, a country's constitution is like that dinner agreement, and a culture that values personal responsibility makes people more likely to honor it.
Constitutions only work if people actually follow them. This paper shows that a country's culture—specifically how individualistic its society is—strongly predicts whether its constitution is respected. That matters because constitutional compliance is linked to economic growth and political stability, and it suggests that formal rules alone aren't enough; the informal cultural environment matters too.
The abstract doesn't say. It covers a cross-section of 115 countries with novel indicators, and the results are robust to instrumental variables, but does not discuss specific limitations.
Ask anything about this paper. Answers come from its abstract, and say so when the abstract doesn't cover your question.
Culture and constitutional compliance — Jerg Gutmann, Anna Lewczuk-Czerwińska, Jacek Lewkowicz et al.
Abstract licence: CC0
Explanation generated by Synthesis from the abstract — it is not the original paper. This is a preprint, so it hasn't necessarily been peer reviewed.